Women world champions can’t stand against male newcomers: is the level of women’s boxing this bad?
A short gym sparring clip involving Claressa Shields has gone viral on social media, sparking renewed debate about the competitive level of women’s boxing. The footage shows Shields being dropped during sparring by a male boxer identified online as Arturs Ahmetovs, with captions suggesting the moment exposes a fundamental gap between elite female champions and male newcomers.
As with many viral clips, the framing has led to sweeping conclusions that deserve closer scrutiny.
Sparring footage is not a measure of professional level
The most important detail often ignored in this discussion is that the incident occurred during sparring, not in a sanctioned bout. Sparring sessions are informal by nature. Fighters test reactions, allow exchanges to play out, and work on specific skills rather than prioritising defence or winning rounds. Moments like knockdowns or heavy shots happen regularly in gyms and are rarely treated as career-defining events.
Claressa Shields’ résumé remains untouched by a sparring clip. She is an Olympic gold medalist and a multi-division world champion who has consistently defeated the best available opposition in women’s boxing. Those achievements are the standard by which her level should be judged, not a brief gym exchange recorded on a phone.
Another key factor is biological difference. Combat sports are divided by sex and weight to account for disparities in strength, power, and physical durability. On average, men carry greater punching power and muscle mass even at similar weights, which becomes evident in mixed-gender sparring regardless of experience. A male newcomer landing a telling shot on a female professional does not automatically reflect a lack of skill on her part, nor does it undermine the quality of women’s boxing as a whole.
SHOP: Kickboxing Equipment
The debate also highlights a broader misunderstanding of how sports are evaluated. Women’s boxing should be assessed within its own competitive structure, just as lighter men are not compared directly with heavyweights. Over the past decade, the women’s game has seen clear improvements in technique, depth, and global exposure, even if development pathways and financial support still lag behind the men’s side.
The viral clip ultimately says more about social media’s appetite for controversy than it does about the state of women’s boxing. Isolated sparring moments, stripped of context, are a poor substitute for evaluating years of elite-level competition inside the ring.
READ MORE: “I Have to Accept That” – Jiri Prochazka Prepared to Miss Baby’s Birth for UFC Title Shot
Recent posts
